Stuffed Sugar Cookie

What happens when you strip down a Gideon’s Cookie and fill it with Buttercream Goodness? Say hello to Gideon’s Stuffed Sugar Cookies! For November we are dropping a different Sugar Cookie each week! 🚨 For Sugar Cookie East End Preorders, you will receive the one that lands on the day of your pickup. Each flavor is ONLY in production on the days listed IE you can’t pick up a week one flavor in week three, for example.

November 1st to 7th

Vanilla Cream Cheese: This is the OG stuffed Gideon’s Cookie! A Vanilla Bean Sugar Cookie stuffed with a delicious Cream Cheese Frosting! Rolled in crunchy Sugar Crystals.

November 8th to 14th

Chocolate Peanut Butter: Our Multi-Chocolate Sugar Dough stuffed with a Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Buttercream. A respectable representation of the power combo of PB+Chocolate. Rolled in crunchy Sugar Crystals!

November 15th to 21st

Birthday Cake: Vanilla Bean Sugar Cookie stuffed with a weirdly blue Birthday Cake Cream Cheese Buttercream! In celebration of a very special birthday this week! Covered in crunchy multicolored Nonpareils (which I don’t classify as sprinkles, FYI).

November 22nd to 30th

Pumpkin Cheesecake: A worthy dessert for your Thanksgiving day spread! A flavorful Pumpkin Sugar Cookie stuffed with a yummy Pumpkin Cheesecake Buttercream! Top it with crunchy Sugar Crystals and you’re ready for a couch nap.

📆 Choose Your Pickup Date During the Checkout Process!