Putting this right out there, we don’t have a public phone number. Due to the excessive amount of requests asking for holds and stock levels we had to discontinue that access to keep our shop moving. With that said, we are pretty quick to answer your questions via email! Fill out our form here, your message will get filtered to the best person for the job and they will be in touch within 24 business hours!
$5 each & nearly ½ pound!
Max of 6 cookies for instore purchase, but that’s almost 3 pounds of cookies, so not too bad! Head to our 72hr local pickup page to order as many as you want!
The Gideon’s Original Chocolate Chip is the foundation of who we are, the first child. This recipe took 15 years to perfect and is filled with history. It is packed inside and out with a variety of Chocolates, infused with differing vanillas, and has a texture that might almost trick you into thinking you’re eating Cookie Dough. This Cookie has been named everything from Best in Orlando to Best on Planet Earth and we couldn’t be prouder to hand make it from scratch for you daily.
This Cookie took an extra-long time to perfect! We wanted you to enjoy something that was truly set apart from the standard flavor for a PB cookie. We’re very proud that our Peanut Butter Crunch is perfectly peanut buttery with every bite. Not surprising since the dough is made of mostly peanut butter! It’s topped with our handmade candied peanuts for the perfect amount of crunch. A must for any PB Lover.
We have come to know this one as our Cult Cookie. People who love it want everyone else to obsess over it along with them. Why? It’s like a Cookies & Cream milkshake in a cookie. It starts with our ultra-soft vanilla bean cookie filled with chunks of hand-cut Double Stuff. We top it with a complete covering over crushed cookies to solidify Cookies & Cream in a way you’ve never experienced. Not that prettiest but so sweet and tasty.
We don’t like typical walnut cookies. The nuts get rubbery in cookies as soft and buttery as ours. So we leveled the walnut cookie up by topping it with our double-baked Candied Walnuts and hand placing each one all over the top of our Original Chocolate Chip Cookie. This Cookie is a huge time-consuming pain to make so we offer it for walkup service only on “Walnut Wednesday” or as a preorder item when you just can’t wait.
available only at
East End Market
A long-standing favorite in our community, this flavorful cookie mixes our favorite chocolate chips with crunchy toffee pieces. Top that off with lightly salted pistachios and perfection is achieved. Sweet and Salty. Soft and Crunchy. Known for being our most sophisticated and addictively flavor, this is the cookie that the Orlando Weekly suggests you try first.
Our Triple Chocolate (which is really 5 kinds of chocolate) is made with fancy Callebaut and Ghirardelli chocolates to name a few. To make it extra velvety we pour our chocolate ganache straight into the cookie dough as we’re mixing it. This is the Cookie you just want to curl up with, our most emotional Cookie.
When an entire cookie is just too much or you need to take your cookie experience to the next level, we present to you the Gideon’s Bite. These “Bites” are quartered Gideon’s Cookies completely dipped in chocolate and sprinkled with toppings. Mix & Match with your Preorder. Perfect for events. Perfect for gifts. Perfect with great coffee. Perfect!
The Rocky Rock is a gourmet Cookie set to the max at every single step. Step One: Start with our amazingly velvety Triple Chocolate Cookie base. Step Two: Mix in our housemade double-baked Candied Almonds. Step 3: Top it with the best from-scratch marshmallows in Orlando from the wonderful ladies at Sugar Rush Marshmallows. Step 4: Set that Cookie on Fire!
$7 Per Slice – Big enough to share!
We won’t lie, this one is our favorite. Most Red Velvet you find these days is just chocolate cake with red food coloring but our masterpiece is a traditional buttermilk based cake. Insanely moist and heavily layered with the thick waves of cream cheese frosting then lined in our double baked candied walnuts.
At Gideon’s we’re known for having the most melt-in-your-mouth Chocolate Cake in a wonderful variety of favorite flavors ranging from Peanut Butter Cup to Andes Mint Cookies & Cream Cake! They change daily so keep an eye on what each location has to offer and come in on the day that matches your taste buds!
This is a special item for those who know what’s up. Follow us on Instagram and Facebook and watch out for posts about special super Secret Slices! They are flavors completely off menu when our bakers get to really explore. Once announced you’ll have to give us the special promoted password to obtain a slice. It won’t be advertised in shop. These are always extra limited so move fast! While Supplies Last! Limited 1 Per Customer.
We love to dip desserts in chocolate so why not do it with slices of our Giant Cookie Cakes? We have fun dipping generous slices of all different flavors of our Cookie Cakes paired with a layer of buttercream before dipping. We love to make these for special occasions or any excuse, really.
These are just here to build anticipation.
A creamy Peanut Butter mixed with freshly ground 431 blend Espresso from the award-winning Lineage Coffee. Topped with chocolate and our small batch house-made candied peanuts for the perfect amount of crunch with your cookie. So unique! So Flavorful!!
This beauty is a Caramel laced Chocolate Chip Cookie topped with Shaved Roasted Coconut! None of that weird chewy coconut here! Fresh and delicious!
Enjoy flavors of Cinnamon, Ancho Chile, Dulce de Leche swirls, and a little Cayenne to bring some heat. Topped with beautifully textured Mexican and Dark Chocolates for that combo of crunchy and creamy. 🇲🇽🍪🔥
A new crowd favorite and a great Cookie to launch the New Year!! Filled and topped with freshly ground beans from our friends at Lineage Coffee Roasting and complemented with notes of Toffee and Chocolate in our Vanilla Bean Cookie! So sophisticated!
We can’t just give you a standard White Chocolate Cookie! Our homemade Salted Caramel is what makes this cookie so extra special. The caramel bakes right in and sometimes even explodes right out to offer you a cookie that is fun and packed with flavors. A Gideon’s Team favorite! You’ll find this one everyone November!
All the goodness of our rich and velvety Triple Chocolate Cookie (which is really five kinds of chocolate) with the added bonus of cool and refreshing chopped Andes Mint (which makes it SIX kinds of chocolate)! During the 24 hour process we take to make our Cookies, that mint soaks into every ounce of that almost 1/2 pound ball of chocolate dough creating the perfect chocolate mint experience with every bite!
Behold the Santa’s White Christmas Cookie featuring the popular flavor from Barnies Coffee! This White Chocolate Chip Cookie is filled with notes of Coconut, Sweet Caramel, Vanilla, and Nutty Flavors. We take it a step further by adding freshly ground White Christmas coffee beans throughout the Cookie. Our Cookie Elves then add the crunch of coarse sugar, our signature sea salt, and a pinch of Christmas glitter!!
Our most popular and irresponsible Cookie of the Year! The Frankenstein is a Halloween month celebration, made from pieces parts of all the candies you want in your bag, and topped with M&M’s that we lovingly place on the top OCD style to be sure you get all the colors. Break it open and you’ll find crushed Oreo Double Stuff and Chocolate Pieces.
Our crazy-popular Coffee Cake Cookie is an extra Buttery Vanilla Bean Cookie filled with Cinnamon Swirl and topped with our Homemade Double Baked Butter Crumbs! Buttery. Crunchy. Amazing. It’s like a Snickerdoodle in its final evolution! Built to be paired with our Original line of Bottled Coffees.
This Valentine’s month Cookie is pure Passion! Our Velvety Five Flavor Chocolate Cookie is laced with our special house-made Ancho, Cayenne, and Cinnamon Spice Mix and topped with Chocolate Covered Cherries. It’s a deep chocolate flavor that is followed by the tingling warmth of a first kiss and sweet aftertaste of cherries. The one you’ve been waiting for your entire life is here and it loves you without condition, eternally.