PB & Jelly Cake



A Limited Edition Cake so popular we had to keep it around! The Peanut Butter & Jelly Cake is the real deal! This one is perfection in its simplicity. Start with three layers of our delicate Vanilla Cake as the bread. Smother that cake in our Peanut Butter Buttercream (one of my biggest addictions) and fill that PB with channels of real Grape Jelly! This is your childhood rolled into one heavy Gideon’s Cake.


All Gideon’s Cakes are 8 inch three layer cakes that can feed up to 20 people! Available for local pickup only at our location in East End Market. You can order this item up to 30 days in advance but we need at least a 72 hour notice.